More than 5 years into this industry, I’ve seen how affiliate marketing has changed. Brands that once relied on coupon websites, cashback and traditional publishers/bloggers are increasingly working with creators and influencers, often through hybrid partnerships that combine a fixed fee with performance-based commission.
But as these partnerships evolve, so does the question of how to measure them. When a creator introduces a product, a publisher helps someone compare options and a coupon website eventually drives the purchase, which partner actually contributed to the sale? And did the partnership generate additional business or simply claim credit for a purchase that was going to happen anyway?
The affiliate channel itself is healthy with spending reaching nearly $14 billion in 2024, up 50% from 2021, according to the Performance Marketing Association's industry study. What hasn't kept up is the way brands measure what their partners contribute.
The question, then, might not be whether affiliate marketing is dying. It's whether the traditional performance model can account for the way people actually discover and buy products today.
With Black Friday and the Christmas shopping season approaching, that question becomes particularly relevant. When everyone is competing for the same customers, understanding what drives a sale and what creates demand in the first place matters more than ever.
The problem with measuring every partnership by its last click
Affiliate marketing has an appealing proposition. Businesses pay partners when they generate a defined result, usually a sale. Unlike advertising models that charge for exposure, affiliate commissions can be directly tied to measurable outcomes.
There's a catch. A tracked conversion tells you which partner received credit for a purchase. It doesn't tell you who influenced the decision, how the customer discovered the brand or whether the sale would have happened without that partner.
Let’s take a customer who discovers a beauty brand through a creator they follow. They watch several videos and start considering a purchase. A few weeks later, during Black Friday, they search for a discount code and complete their order through a coupon website. The coupon partner receives the affiliate commission, while the creator who first introduced the product receives nothing. The coupon partner may have genuinely helped convert the customer. But the final click only shows where the customer completed their journey, not what influenced them along the way.
Most businesses still use last-click attribution as the main metric even as investment in creator and influencer partnerships grow. Brands are paying to grow one kind of partnership while measuring success in a way that rewards another.
Today, different partners contribute at different stages. Creators introduce products to new audiences, publishers help customers compare options and coupon websites help shoppers who are already considering a purchase to complete it. Those contributions won't show up in the same place in an attribution report.
Both kinds of contribution can be valuable, but they need to be evaluated differently. If every partner is judged by the same immediate return, brands risk over-investing in those closest to checkout and overlooking the ones creating demand earlier on.
Why peak season makes this harder
Black Friday and Christmas put the most pressure on brands to show revenue, which makes immediately attributable sales attractive. A partner generating hundreds of conversions looks like a strong performer next to a creator whose content drives engagement and traffic but fewer direct purchases.
Discount-driven shopping also makes it harder to distinguish between creating demand and capturing it. Many peak-season shoppers have already decided what to buy and are comparing prices. A coupon website might help them choose where to buy, but that doesn't mean it introduced them to the brand.
Every commission is a cost. If a partner is getting credit for purchases that would have happened anyway, the brand needs to ask whether that commission is buying anything. The same reflection should apply to creators. A large audience doesn't guarantee new customers, just as an attributed sale doesn't prove incrementality. The goal isn't to favor one type of partner over another, but to understand what each contributes and whether it justifies the cost.
What should brands measure instead?
Moving beyond last-click attribution doesn't mean abandoning performance measurement. It means matching the way partnerships are evaluated to what they're actually expected to achieve.
Start with the data. Affiliate platforms track referrals and commissions, commerce platforms hold transaction data and customer databases hold repeat purchases. When these systems don't talk to each other, connecting partner activity to real customer behavior is close to impossible, and no attribution model, however sophisticated, can fill that gap.
With the data connected, each partnership can be judged against what it's meant to do. For discovery, this would be relevant reach, branded search trends and referral traffic. For consideration, look at product-page visits, email signups and assisted conversions. For conversion, check sales, commission cost, conversion rate, average order value and the share of new customers, followed by retention and lifetime value.
The more useful question is how these measurements connect. If a creator drives a lot of referral traffic but few immediate purchases, are those visitors coming back through other channels? Are branded searches rising? Are new customers being acquired at a reasonable cost, and how do they behave compared with customers from other partners?
Answering these questions can help businesses make better decisions about where to allocate their budgets. It might mean increasing investment in a partner whose contribution extends beyond the final click, adjusting commission structures for partners who mainly capture existing demand, or reconsidering a partnership that generates activity without results.
The most reliable way to estimate incrementality is to test it. Pause a coupon partner in one market, or withhold a discount code from part of a creator's audience, and compare the results with a control group. If sales barely move without the partner, the commission was paying for demand the brand already had. Attribution models can add context, but they can't replace a test, and they won't fix incomplete data.
From acquisition to long-term loyalty
A customer acquired through a creator partnership or a discount promotion might become a valuable repeat customer, or might never buy again. The first sale doesn't tell you which.
Looking at what happens next can help businesses understand whether their affiliate strategy is contributing to sustainable growth. Do customers acquired through particular partners return? Do they buy different products? Are they more responsive to certain types of communication? Does the acquisition cost still make sense when repeat purchases are taken into account?
That also depends on the rest of the business. Product availability, delivery and customer service all influence whether someone comes back. Marketing can bring someone through the door, but the rest of the business decides whether they stay.
Affiliate marketing isn't dead, but the old assumptions need revisiting
If every partnership is expected to generate immediate last-click sales, businesses risk favoring partners closest to checkout while overlooking those helping customers discover and evaluate their products. Moving in the opposite direction and measuring success through awareness alone isn't the answer either. Reach and engagement need to connect to commercial outcomes if brands want to understand the return on their investment.
The real opportunity is to look beyond individual conversions and understand how partnerships contribute to the wider customer journey. That means combining performance data with a better understanding of customer acquisition, incrementality and long-term value.
As peak season approaches, this is a chance for businesses to evaluate what their affiliate programs are actually delivering. Not just how many sales their partners generate, but how many of those sales represent genuine growth.
I suppose that leaves us with this final question.
Are brands measuring the value their partners create or simply rewarding the part of the customer journey their tracking can see?




