🎧 Listen to the full episode here.

‍

Many retailers put considerable effort into getting customers to earn points. But what happens once those points are in their accounts? When a loyalty program offers little beyond discounts on future purchases, the points can start to feel less like a reward and more like another sales promotion. The real test comes when members are ready to redeem. Is there something worth choosing and is it easy to claim?

On The Open Podcast, Sander Mangel speaks with Gabi Kool, CEO of Loylogic, about what makes a loyalty program worth participating in. Drawing on more than 25 years in the industry and experience working with brands including KLM and airBaltic, Gabi shares how businesses can create more meaningful rewards, encourage members to redeem, and build programs that deliver lasting value for both customers and the business.

‍

Points are a mechanism, not the reward

For Gabi, one of the biggest misconceptions about loyalty programs is that giving customers points is enough. Points are simply the mechanism that gets customers to a reward. What matters is what they can actually do with them and whether that experience makes them feel recognized by the brand.

He explains that, “if you just offer coupons then you've built a very elegant coupon scheme, but that doesn't really touch the hearts and minds of your consumers.”

Gabi sees discounts as the least sticky part of a program. A coupon comes with a catch. The customer has to spend more money to benefit, which doesn't feel like receiving a reward they've earned.

He illustrates this with a simple analogy. Imagine attending a close friend's 50th birthday after knowing them for years, only to give them a generic gift card. It wouldn’t communicate thoughtfulness or appreciation.

As he puts it, “our job is to make sure that our clients, these loyalty programs, never become the lazy friend to their best customers.”

‍

Why the first redemption matters more than you think

One of the most important moments in a loyalty program is the first time a member actually redeems their points. Businesses often focus on how quickly customers earn, but Gabi argues that the time it takes to reach that first reward deserves just as much attention.

“There’s kind of a beautiful saying in our industry which is called burn drives earn.” he shares.

In loyalty terminology, earning refers to collecting points, while burning means redeeming them. The idea is that redemption creates a positive experience that encourages customers to return and earn more. Gabi says the sooner members redeem for the first time, the more likely they are to stay engaged, which makes time to first redemption an important metric to track.

That does not mean every reward needs to be available immediately. Long-term rewards give members something to work toward, but they should be balanced with smaller opportunities along the way. Gabi recommends testing how much progress members need before they become invested, though it tends to be around 30 to 40% of the way to a reward. At that point, “they basically are vested in the program.”

One way to keep members engaged in the meantime is to run monthly raffles alongside the points scheme, funded from a fixed marketing budget. Members who don't win can automatically enter a year-end grand prize draw, so even a “lucky loser” still has something to look forward to.

The goal isn't necessarily to encourage members to redeem as often as possible. Gabi says the important thing is to offer a relevant selection of rewards and let members decide whether they want to save for something bigger or redeem smaller rewards along the way. What Loylogic tries to avoid is offering rewards that require so few points that the program starts to feel like a discount scheme again.

‍

Think about the behavior you want to change

Before deciding which rewards to offer, businesses need to understand what they want the program to achieve. Gabi says one of the first questions Loylogic asks clients is: “What is the behavior that you're trying to change or reward?”

The answer might be repeat purchases or a higher average basket value. However, loyalty can also support goals like moving customers to cheaper digital channels, collecting product feedback or encouraging recommendations. Gabi groups these into three categories: revenue, cost savings and brand building. Businesses can then list potential behaviors and assess how much each could contribute to customer lifetime value.

Sometimes the most valuable behavior is one nobody would have guessed. One of Loylogic's banking clients identified an unexpected opportunity. It was cheaper for the bank when customers withdrew cash at supermarket checkouts rather than at competing banks' ATMs. That became a potential behavior to incentivize.

“That would have never been a trigger that would have come in my mind,” Gabi admits.

It also changes how the program is funded. Loyalty should not automatically be treated as a marketing expense if the behaviors it encourages create value elsewhere in the organization.

‍

A reward is also a promise

Points represent a future obligation. Customers collect them expecting to exchange them for something of value and the business needs to be ready to honor that promise. Gabi has seen programs run into trouble when nobody set funding aside. Sometimes the manager who launched a successful program moves on, and their successor inherits a growing points balance with no budget behind it. The knee-jerk response is to devalue points or remove popular rewards, and the program becomes “a victim of its own success.”

His advice is to be conservative. Rather than counting on “breakage,” the industry term for points that are never used, businesses should plan for the full obligation and treat expired points as a later benefit.

‍

Make the reward worth the effort

Loylogic shapes this part of a program around what it calls its 8 beliefs: emotion, money can't buy, value, selection, branding and curation, reward shopper ID, ways of shopping, and sharing. Together, they describe what makes a reward feel like a real thank you.

Several of them come down to the catalog. A strong reward catalog needs enough variety to appeal to different members while staying relevant to the brand.

“Don't offer everything and anything just because you can,” Gabi says.

Rewards should feel like a natural extension of the brand, and they should make each member feel known. The goal is to get to know the individual member, not just the segment.

Then there's value. Points should go a little further than members expect. That's one reason airline loyalty programs work so well. The perceived value of a mile when redeemed for a flight is often higher than the actual cost to the airline.

Experiences that money cannot buy can create an even stronger connection. Gabi suggests a fashion brand could offer a behind-the-scenes look before a major show. At one Northern European airline, members bid their miles for time in a flight simulator with the CEO, a trained pilot.

Even the most exciting reward loses its appeal if redeeming it is difficult. Redemption should meet the standards of good e-commerce: clear product information, local payment options, few clicks and smooth delivery. Sander knows the opposite well. His favorite hotel chain gives him free upgrades every year, but redeeming them means calling ahead. “At that point I'm just like, whatever, it's fine.”

For Gabi, redemption “needs to be a festive moment.” Get it right and members will want to tell others about it, which is Loylogic's final belief, sharing, and exactly what a program wants.

‍

Measuring loyalty beyond marketing metrics

For loyalty to receive sustained support, it needs to make sense beyond the marketing department. Clicks and likes don't tell a CFO what the program is worth.

Gabi suggests a metric Loylogic developed with a partner. That is, member equity, the collective expected future profit of a program's members. Scoring members on customer lifetime value each month shows whether that value is rising or falling, and frames the investment clearly, for example reinvesting 2% of member revenue back into the program.

Ultimately, the rewards need to reflect the brand, feel valuable, be financially sustainable and be easy to claim. Get those right and customers have a reason to participate beyond collecting points.

Gabi returns to one simple idea at the end of the conversation: “If loyalty members redeem a reward that they love, trust me, they will come back to earn more.” That is the thinking behind burn drives earn. The points may get customers started, but the reward is what gives them a reason to stay.

‍

‍

Watch the full episode featuring Gabi Kool on The Open Podcast YouTube channel. Subscribe on LinkedIn for more e-commerce insights and conversations from the Open Commerce team.

‍